Mute tab broken for pinned tabs

Mattches · June 7, 2022, 6:12pm

We have an open issue for this here on our Github:

Selecting a pinned tab with sound playing mutes the audio

opened 07:29PM - 05 Apr 22 UTC

priority/P3 feature/pinned-tabs QA/Yes release-notes/include audio OS/Desktop

## Description When a pinned tab is playing audio content, if you navigate away from that tab, then back again, selecting the pinned tab mutes the audio. This is likely due to the "speaker" icon being (or at least being detected as) clicked when trying to select the pinned tab with small real estate. Further, clicking the speaker icon on the pinned tab again to _unmute_ does not work (its unresponsive). Right-clicking on the pinned tab shows the `Mute tab` option even though the tab is already muted. If `Mute tab` is selected from the context menu, the tab remains muted. If you right-click again after, the context menu _now_ says `Unmute tab` — however, selecting this option _still does not unmute the tab_. ![image](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/3299098/161833697-b7554f0a-95c6-4a48-ba02-4ac902eea186.png) ![image](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/3299098/161833820-332ad7eb-aee2-4476-b11b-ab8416ac1d37.png) The only way to actually unmute the pinned tab is to unpin the tab, then click the speaker icon (which works without issue). ## Steps to Reproduce 1. Pin a tab 2. Play audio in that tab 3. Select another tab 4. Click on the pinned tab to select it ## Actual result: Observe audio from the pinned tab is muted and cannot be easily unmuted, as described above. ## Expected result: Tab should be selected, not muted ## Reproduces how often: Always ## Brave version (brave://version info) 1.37.111 Chromium: 100.0.4896.79 (Official Build) (arm64) ## Version/Channel Information: - Can you reproduce this issue with the current release? Yes - Can you reproduce this issue with the beta channel? Yes - Can you reproduce this issue with the nightly channel? Yes ## Miscellaneous Information: User report here: https://community.brave.com/t/pinned-tab-mutes-on-click-and-cant-be-unmuted/365423

Topic		Replies	Views
Pinned tab mutes on click and can't be unmuted Desktop Support windows	10	1552	May 6, 2022
Mute Icon on Pinned Tab Bug(s) Desktop Support macos	2	527	May 25, 2022
Can't unmute pinned tabs Desktop Support windows	3	913	August 28, 2022
Unable to unmute tab once muted on pin mode Desktop Support linux	3	398	August 20, 2022
Pinned muted tabs can't be unmuted browser	5	1032	July 12, 2022
Unable to mute pinned tabs Desktop Support macos	7	1149	March 22, 2020
Sound icon on pinned tab Desktop Support windows	4	527	July 17, 2022
Pinned tabs can't be unmuted Desktop Support macos	3	493	May 12, 2022

Mute tab broken for pinned tabs

Related topics