Chrome / Chromium "Manifest V3" and Brave

Chrome (and hence, Chromium-based browsers … presumably including Brave) will implement “Manifest V3” starting in January 2023. Here are some details from a recent Google blog post.

This isn’t new news. An Electronic Frontier Foundation post from December 2021 doesn’t pull its punches or candy-coat its critical opinion of “Manifest V3”. Here’s another more recent detailed discussion from Ars Technica I’ve read.

I’m unclear how — if at all — “Manifest V3” will affect Brave users. Both the EFF post and the discussion in Ars suggest use of ad-blocking extensions will be impacted, but I’ve read no discussion of whether “Manifest V3” will affect how stuff like Brave’s privacy-protecting “shields” will be affected.

Comments?

It does not uses the extension API, it will not be affected.

3 Likes

I made a post that brave should make a official blog post on the topic. They have made few tweets on the topic.

Brave shields (adblocking, tracker blocking, anti-fingerprinting) will not be affected by MV3 whatsoever.

Also, google has shifted the timeline from Jan 2023 to Jun 2023 for stable release and till Jan 2024 for enterprise release. Brave will support the enterprise policy meaning MV2 will be available on brave till Jan 2024.

2 Likes

Looks like various developers already started updating their browser extension to Manifest V3

True, but v3 extenstions are also limited in functionality currently

I received a mail yesterday from SIMKL, they had to completely rewrite their Browser Extension to Manifest V3

Here: https://simkl.com/apps/chrome/enhancer/updated/

I think this might, indirectly kill all those outdated apps, which never received any update for ages.

Bumping this with a link to a 5 Aug 2024 discussion of Manifest V3.

The Ars article makes no mention of Brave (though some comments do). Some links within the Ars article lead to additional reporting that Brave (and some other Chromium-based browsers) will continue - for now - to support Manifest V2, hence, (one can hope) some extensions not compliant with Manifest V3.

Here’s the link to the Brave Settings page for currently-supported Manifest V2 extensions:

brave://settings/extensions/v2

1 Like